Back to Food & Dining

the best pizza

For The Health Of It avatar
Beach Fanatic
9,963 views
Several months ago, the food network did a competition between Chicago deep dish and New York Thin slice pizza. The show featured firefighters from both cities comparing pizza. New york won in a close race.

I just spent the past week in Chicago and sampled what many people call the best pizza in the city. I was not impressed. In fact last night, my first night back, I went to eat at the best pizza place of them all, Amore.

The carmalized onion-roasted garlic thin slice right here has Chi-town beat hands down.

Thanks Amore:clap_1: :clap_1:

Replies

48
SoWal Insider
#2
Several months ago, the food network did a competition between Chicago deep dish and New York Thin slice pizza. The show featured firefighters from both cities comparing pizza. New york won in a close race.

I just spent the past week in Chicago and sampled what many people call the best pizza in the city. I was not impressed. In fact last night, my first night back, I went to eat at the best pizza place of them all, Amore.

The carmalized onion-roasted garlic thin slice right here has Chi-town beat hands down.

Thanks Amore:clap_1: :clap_1:
Just curious, which pizza did you have, where? There are so many variations that are in constant competition & comparison. Some are NOT as good as touted to be, imo.

My husband had pizza in Sedona last year (thin crust, etc.) and says it was the best he's ever had!

Edited

Kurt avatar
Admin
#3
I love Amore'! To me it's as close to the pizza you get in Italy as you can get without the local Italian water, ingredients, and old wood-fired ovens.

Some differ - a couple I know here that lived in NYC says you can't get real pizza in SoWal - that it's all "frou-frou designer pizza". :lol:
John R avatar
needs to get out more
#4
if i wanted to reminisce about ny pizza, all i have to do is go to the frozen food section in publix, red sauce and cheese.

if i want the best pizza evah, all i have to do is go to Amore.
Teresa avatar
SoWal Guide
#5
ummmmmmmmmmmm. amore'.... :wub:
Smiling JOe avatar
SoWal Expert
#6
I actually like NY style pizza when done right, but it is difficult to find it done right around here. Chicago style pizza is the pits. They should stick to cold weather which is what they do best.

Amore pizza is most definitely the best around here within at least a 60 mile radius. In my opinion, it is second only to Marco's Pizza in Asheville NC, the gold standard by which I measure all pizzas. Amore's pizza crust is actually better (crispier) than Marco's, but Marco's, yummy! My problem is it is an 18 hour round trip to get Marco's and only 20 minutes round trip to get Amore's pizza. :wub: ... but I'm not certain that it is really a problem for me.

Edited

Teresa avatar
SoWal Guide
#7
ya'll are making me hungry! and amore's isn't open yet!!!
Smiling JOe avatar
SoWal Expert
#8
ya'll are making me hungry! and amore's isn't open yet!!!
and they have always been closed on Tuesdays, but I think I saw an add recently that they will be open for lunch on Tuesdays... :idontno: Where is our precious Olive?
SoWal Insider
#9
Chicago style pizza is the pits. They should stick to cold weather which is what they do best.
Wow! ouch. Not real sure what that means but that's ok. :idontno:
barefootguy avatar
Beach Fanatic
#10
I lived in the Chicago area for 39 years, and my favorite pizza was always Domino's!

Now I think I prefer Papa John's.

Edited

Kurt avatar
Admin
#11
They should stick to cold weather which is what they do best.

:lolabove:
Smiling JOe avatar
SoWal Expert
#12
Wow! ouch. Not real sure what that means but that's ok. :idontno:
Not made to be an insult. I know many people who have lived in Chicago, and many others who visit for the food, but I've never heard any of them talk about the pizza. ;-) Generally speaking, I think people from the mid-west are pretty cool people.
JC avatar
Beach Lover
#13
Where is Amore?
picky
#14
Several months ago, the food network did a competition between Chicago deep dish and New York Thin slice pizza. The show featured firefighters from both cities comparing pizza. New york won in a close race.

I just spent the past week in Chicago and sampled what many people call the best pizza in the city. I was not impressed. In fact last night, my first night back, I went to eat at the best pizza place of them all, Amore.

The carmalized onion-roasted garlic thin slice right here has Chi-town beat hands down.

Thanks Amore:clap_1: :clap_1:

I don't think you can really compare the two. It's like comparing salmon and swordfish: the only thing they have in common is that they're both fish. Chicago pizza and NY pizza are much the same thing. I personally like them both but I'd never put them in a contest together.
Franny avatar
Beach Fanatic
#15
Gulf Place.
SoWal Insider
#16
Not made to be an insult. I know many people who have lived in Chicago, and many others who visit for the food, but I've never heard any of them talk about the pizza. ;-) Generally speaking, I think people from the mid-west are pretty cool people.
Some Chicagoans swear by Chicago deep-dish pizza as being the "end all, be all." Some of it is really very good. And you hear disagreements & comparisons regularly. I've never tasted any from NY so can't judge theirs; it's probably wonderful. But it is all a taste preference. Like some Italian spaghetti sauces, their regions of Italy, etc. Mr. JR (born and reared in Chicago) does not like deep-dish, Chicago style pizza. Thinks it's all a bunch of hype.

But actually, Chicago pizza is probably thier claim to fame in the food department. ;-)
goofer avatar
Beach Fanatic
#18
Just curious, which pizza did you have, where? There are so many variations that are in constant competition & comparison. Some are NOT as good as touted to be, imo.

My husband had pizza in Sedona last year (thin crust, etc.) and says it was the best he's ever had!

I live in Sedona and the best pizza in town is APIZZA HEAVEN.
I am originally from NY and there are many places in Manhattan that make extraordinary pizzas. My favorite pizzerias use coal fired ovens. Some of the best are Patsy's in East Harlem, Arturo's, and Grimaldis right near the Bklyn Bridge. But the best pizza in all of America, imo, is Pizzeria Bianco in South Phoenix, AZ !! It was recently featured on Oprah.
Beachmom avatar
Beach Fanatic
#19
Felini's in Atlanta!! Love Amore here, but can't head north without stopping at Felini's.:clap_1:
SoWal Insider
#20
I live in Sedona and the best pizza in town is APIZZA HEAVEN.
I am originally from NY and there are many places in Manhattan that make extraordinary pizzas. My favorite pizzerias use coal fired ovens. Some of the best are Patsy's in East Harlem, Arturo's, and Grimaldis right near the Bklyn Bridge. But the best pizza in all of America, imo, is Pizzeria Bianco in South Phoenix, AZ !! It was recently featured on Oprah.
He said they had to wait almost an hour to be seated! It must've been heavenly because he's not a foodie by any means. He still mentions it regularly!

I saw that Oprah piece. They mentioned Chicago's famous Due's Pizzeria and Uno's. :clap_1:
whiteyfunn avatar
SoWal Staff
#21
Did you know they are more than 50 threads mentioning AMORE?
olive avatar
Beach Fanatic
#22
and they have always been closed on Tuesdays, but I think I saw an add recently that they will be open for lunch on Tuesdays... :idontno: Where is our precious Olive?


Here I am! Out of town. We are closed on Tuesday. Gotta see my man some time!!

:biggrin:

Thanks for all the love!!
JB avatar
Beach Fanatic
#23
Amore is very good, no doubt. But it's just too far a drive if you are staying in in Seagrove or points east (at least for takeout). Spicy Noodle is pretty decent if you are on that end of 30-A
John R avatar
needs to get out more
#24
Did you know they are more than 50 threads mentioning AMORE?

a testiment to it's greatness.
Beach Runner avatar
beats on hood
#25
I used to love Gino's in Chicago. Never missed it when we were there, even though we also visited the five-star restaurants in Chicago, so it's not as though we have no sense of taste.

But my taste buds have gravitated towards a thinner crust with just the right amount of yeastiness, yet crispiness. My favorite pizza is the appetizer at Floataway Caf? in Atlanta with the perfect microgreens on top, along with other toppings. But Amor? is pretty good in comparison. When in Italy, I like a thin pizza Margherita, heavy on the fresh basil.
joho avatar
Beach Fanatic
#26
Amore is very good, no doubt. But it's just too far a drive if you are staying in in Seagrove or points east (at least for takeout). Spicy Noodle is pretty decent if you are on that end of 30-A

It's worth the drive...............
Their Ceaser's salad is good too! :wub:

Checking your forum account

Please wait while we verify your forum account.